Health insurance is perhaps the most critical benefit that a small business in New York can give to its employees. In 2025, when healthcare costs are climbing, and there is a change in workforce expectations, picking the right health insurance plan is not only about following regulations but also about protecting your people, managing expenses, and being competitive in the market.
Why Offer Health Insurance as a Small Business?
Even though it is not a legal requirement for businesses with less than 50 full-time employees to provide insurance, many businesses in New York decide to do so, and they have good reasons for that.
- Attract and retain talent
- Boost employee morale and productivity
- Lower turnover and hiring costs
- Take advantage of tax deductions and potential federal tax credits
Giving out a good health plan is no longer just a luxury; it has become a crucial factor for a business to be sustainable and attractive to the market.
Health Insurance Market for NY Small Businesses
In NY, a small business is defined as an organization consisting of 1 to 100 full-time equivalent employees which have several options to offer health insurance. The state, which employs a community rating system, means that premiums will not reflect the health of the group but the age, place of residence, and family size—thus giving small businesses a fair chance.
Let’s get more specific regarding the primary alternatives for 2025.
- New York State of Health Small Business Marketplace (SHOP)
Primarily the state exchange for small business health insurance, the SHOP market is the place where access to ACA-compliant plans from best carriers is via:
- Fidelis Care
- Healthfirst
- EmblemHealth
- BlueCross BlueShield of Western NY
- UnitedHealthcare (Oxford)
Pros:
- Eligibility for the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit
- Standardized plan tiers (Bronze, Silver, Gold, Platinum)
- Online management and enrollment tools
- No minimum group size
2. Private Market Group Plans (Off-Exchange)
Aside from the exchange, brokers and carriers sell plans that are similar to those on the NY State of Health but The plans follow the ACA regulations as well. Usually, these plans come with more customization and bigger networks.
Popular carriers in NY:
- UnitedHealthcare (Oxford)
- Aetna
- Cigna
- MVP Health Care
- CDPHP
- Empire BlueCross BlueShield
Pros:
- More doctor choices and plan types (PPO, HMO, EPO)
- Ability to access specialty and bundled plans (dental, vision, life)
- A chance to design plans that are compatible with the specific needs of the business
Best for: Those who want to collaborate with a broker for a more customized approach or have a stronger say in designing their network.
3. Level-Funded Plans
They are uprooted plans that even from insured and self-funded plans. Employers pay a fixed monthly rate that covers claims, admin costs, and stop-loss protection. If claims run low, you may receive a year-end refund.
Top Carriers Offering Level-Funded Plans in NY:
- United4. QSEHRA and ICHRA (Reimbursement Models)If managing a traditional group plan is something you want to avoid, reimbursement-based options are going to be a good fit for you in NY.QSEHRA (Qualified Small Employer HRA)Businesses with less than 50 employeesDecide a monthly reimbursement limit (i.e., $350/month per employee)Workers buy their own individual coverage and get a tax-free reimbursement.ICHRA (Individual Coverage HRA)Any size business can use this Reimburse
- Businesses with less than 50 employees
- Decide a monthly reimbursement limit (i.e., $350/month per employee)
- Workers buy their own individual coverage and get a tax-free reimbursement.
- Any size business can use this
- Reimburse
5. Cooperative or Association Health Plans
Through collective bargaining, chambers of commerce and groups of industries in some parts of New York can offer group health plans at lower rates. Most probably, these options will have fewer carriers, but they can be the perfect solution for very small businesses.
Tax Credits for Small Businesses
If you are eligible for a Small Business Health Care Tax Credit, the amount can significantly reduce your expenses.
You may be eligible if:
- You have fewer than 25 full-time equivalent employees
- You pay average wages under $56,000
- You pay at least 50% of the employee-only premium
- You buy insurance through the NY SHOP exchange
Potential Savings:
- Up to 50% of premium contributions for for-profit businesses
- Up to 35% for non-profits
Two consecutive years is the time limit that
How Much Should You Budget?
Here’s a general idea of total monthly employer costs per employee in 2025:
| Plan Type | Monthly Premium | Employer Contribution (Est.) |
| Bronze (High-Deductible) | $450–$550 | $225–$400 |
| Silver | $550–$700 | $300–$500 |
| Gold | $700–$850 | $350–$600 |
| Level-Funded | $500–$650 | Varies (with refund potential) |
| QSEHRA/ICHRA | N/A | You choose (e.g., $200–$400) |
Remember: premiums are community-rated in New York, so costs won’t be affected by the health status of your team.
Tips to Get the Most Value from Your Plan
✅ Work with a Licensed Broker A broker can find a plan for you that can be customized, compare different carriers that fit your needs, and renew the plan no matter if it is at no extra cost to you also.
✅ Bundle Ancillary Benefits By adding additional services like vision, dental, or life insurance, your employees will be more satisfied with their job, and you also could be eligible for multi-line discounts.
✅ Survey Your Employees
To know more about the benefits that people prefer, it may be low deductibles, mental health coverage, telemedicine access, or premium affordability.
✅ Review Annually
Each year, there will be changes in health insurance premiums and coverage options. Always check before renewing.
Final Thoughts
It is not compulsory to be at loss in choosing health insurance for a small business in New York in 2025. Providing coverage of high value with a proper strategy, keeping the team healthy and availing tax credit as well as efficient plan design led savings can be a good combination.
If you decide to go with a SHOP plan, off-exchange, level-funding, or even a flexible HRA model, you will still find a solution that fits your budget, your team, and your growth goals.</
 – Plans, Prices & Tax Credits){kind=link}
0 Comments